Shocks vs. Struts: North Canton Mechanic Explains the Difference

“Do I have shocks or struts?” “What’s the difference between the two?” “When should I replace them?” These are some of the most common questions we hear as North Canton mechanics when discussing suspension problems. And honestly, the confusion is completely understandable—even seasoned car owners often use the terms interchangeably.

As your trusted North Canton mechanic since 2009, we’ll clear up the confusion once and for all. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explain what shocks and struts are, the key differences between them, how to tell which your vehicle has, signs that they need replacement, and why proper suspension maintenance matters—especially on Ohio’s challenging roads.

Understanding Your Vehicle’s Suspension System

Before we dive into shocks vs. struts, let’s quickly understand what your suspension system does:

Primary Functions:

1. Absorbs road impacts - Potholes, bumps, uneven pavement
2. Keeps tires on the road - Maximum traction and control
3. Provides comfortable ride - Smooth out the bumps
4. Maintains vehicle stability - Safe handling and cornering

Your suspension includes springs (coil or leaf), control arms, bushings, sway bars, and either shocks or struts. Springs support your vehicle’s weight and absorb energy from bumps. Shocks or struts control how quickly the springs compress and rebound.

What Are Shock Absorbers (Shocks)?

Definition and Function

Shock absorbers (shocks) are hydraulic damping devices that control the movement of your vehicle’s springs and suspension. Despite the name, they don’t actually “absorb” shocks—the springs do that. Shocks dampen (slow down) the spring’s movement to prevent excessive bouncing.

How Shocks Work

Inside a shock absorber is a piston that moves through hydraulic fluid. When your wheel hits a bump:

1. The spring compresses to absorb the impact
2. The shock’s piston moves through the fluid, creating resistance
3. This resistance slows the spring’s compression and rebound
4. Result: controlled, smooth movement instead of bouncing

Key Characteristics of Shocks

• Not load-bearing: Shocks don’t support your vehicle’s weight
• Mounted separately: Attached between the frame and suspension independently
• Simpler design: Fewer integrated components
• Easier replacement: Generally less expensive labor
• Common locations: Rear suspension on many vehicles, front suspension on trucks/SUVs with separate control arms

"I tell customers to think of shocks like the shock-absorbing padding in a good pair of running shoes. They don't hold you up, but they smooth out your stride and reduce jarring impacts."

CPR 4 Your Car Master Mechanic

What Are Struts?

Definition and Function

Struts are a more complex suspension component that combines several functions into one assembly. A strut is essentially a shock absorber built into a structural support.

How Struts Work

A complete strut assembly includes:

• Shock absorber (damping component inside)
• Coil spring (often integrated, sometimes separate)
• Mounting plate (connects to vehicle body)
• Steering pivot point (on front struts)

Struts perform double duty:

1. Damping: Control spring movement like shocks
2. Structural support: Bear your vehicle’s weight
3. Positioning: Maintain wheel alignment geometry
4. Steering axis: Provide the pivot point for steering (front struts)

Key Characteristics of Struts

• Load-bearing: Major structural component supporting vehicle weight
• Integrated design: Multiple components in one assembly
• More complex: Replacement requires spring compression and alignment
• More expensive: Typically cost more to replace due to complexity
• Common locations: Front suspension on most cars and crossovers; some vehicles have four-wheel strut suspension

Shocks vs. Struts: Key Differences Side-by-Side

How to Tell If Your Vehicle Has Shocks or Struts

Visual Inspection Method

Look Under Your Vehicle:

You Have SHOCKS If You See:

• A separate cylindrical component (shock) mounted between frame and suspension
• The spring is separate from the damping component
• Shocks typically attach at top and bottom with rubber bushings/mounts

You Have STRUTS If You See:

• A large assembly coming up through the wheel well into the engine compartment
• The coil spring is integrated around the strut body
• The top mount is visible under the hood or trunk

Check Your Owner’s Manual

Your vehicle’s owner’s manual will specify whether it has shocks or struts in the suspension specifications section.

Common Patterns by Vehicle Type

While there are exceptions, here are typical configurations:

Usually STRUTS:

• Most passenger cars (Honda Civic, Toyota Camry, etc.)
• Crossover SUVs (Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, etc.)
• Many minivans
• Most front-wheel-drive vehicles

Usually SHOCKS:

• Pickup trucks (front suspension often has shocks)
• Body-on-frame SUVs (Ford Explorer, Chevy Tahoe)
• Rear-wheel-drive performance cars
• Vehicles with independent rear suspension

Mixed Configuration (Common):

• Struts on front, shocks on rear
• Example: Honda Accord has front struts, rear shocks

Signs Your Shocks or Struts Need Replacement

Whether you have shocks or struts, the warning signs of wear are similar:

The Bounce Test (DIY Check)

Here’s a simple test you can do yourself:

1. Park on level ground
2. Push down hard on one corner of your vehicle (front or rear bumper area)
3. Release and observe

Normal: Vehicle bounces once, maybe twice, then settles Worn: Vehicle bounces 3+ times before stopping

Do this test on all four corners. If any corner bounces excessively, those shocks/struts likely need replacement.

When Should Shocks or Struts Be Replaced?

Mileage Guidelines

General Recommendation:

• 50,000 - 100,000 miles depending on driving conditions
• Earlier replacement in harsh climates (like Ohio) or rough roads
• Later replacement possible with highway driving on smooth roads

Best Practice: Have suspension inspected by a professional mechanic at:

• Every 12 months or 12,000 miles
• Immediately if you notice any warning signs
• After any major road impact (deep pothole, curb hit, etc.)

Factors Affecting Lifespan

The Importance of Replacing in Pairs

Shock and Strut Replacement: What to Expect

For Shock Absorber Replacement

Process:

1. Lift vehicle safely
2. Remove wheels for access
3. Disconnect shock mounts (top and bottom)
4. Install new shocks
5. Test drive for proper operation

Time: 1-2 hours for a pair Cost: $150-$400 per pair (parts + labor) Alignment: Not usually required

For Strut Replacement

Process:

1. Lift vehicle safely
2. Remove wheels
3. Disconnect brake lines, ABS sensors (if attached to strut)
4. Remove strut assembly
5. Compress spring using spring compressor (safety critical!)
6. Disassemble strut, replace strut cartridge or complete assembly
7. Reassemble with new mounts/bearings as needed
8. Reinstall strut assembly
9. Perform wheel alignment (always required)
10. Test drive

Time: 2-4 hours for a pair Cost: $300-$700 per pair (parts + labor + alignment) Alignment: ALWAYS REQUIRED after strut replacement

Benefits of New Shocks or Struts

When you replace worn shocks or struts, you’ll notice:

Conclusion: Understanding Your Suspension for Better Maintenance

Now you understand the difference between shocks and struts! While they serve similar purposes—damping your suspension’s movement—struts are complex structural components while shocks are simpler damping devices.

The key takeaways:

• Most vehicles have either shocks OR struts (not both on same axle)
• Struts are more complex and expensive to replace
• Both should be replaced every 50,000-100,000 miles or when symptoms appear
• Always replace in pairs for safety and performance
• Have your suspension inspected annually by a professional mechanic

Whether you have shocks or struts, keeping them in good condition is essential for safety, comfort, and vehicle longevity—especially on North Canton’s challenging roads.

Need suspension service in North Canton? Contact your local mechanic at CPR 4 Your Car. Call (440) 667-8281 or visit us at 8373 Cleveland Ave NW Unit A, North Canton, OH 44720. Professional suspension repair by experienced mechanics serving North Canton since 2009.